The advent of cryptocurrencies, as advanced, encrypted, digital assets, has engendered a transformative paradigm shift in the domain of transnational financial transactions. The advent of cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Ethereum, and Litecoin, among other such currencies, and the foundational technology of blockchain, has implicitly questioned conventional transactional methodologies and posited itself as a prospective game-changer across a range of fiscal sectors. Notwithstanding the transformational potential of these digital currencies and their penetration into the vanguard of international monetary discourse, the discourse surrounding cryptocurrency in Pakistan remains conspicuously cautious. This is primarily attributable to the apparent paucity of a comprehensive regulatory framework governing cryptocurrencies.

In the early phase of the emergence of cryptocurrency, an omnipresent lack of awareness and comprehension about this innovative development catalysed its rapid proliferation. Nevertheless, with a deepening understanding and clearer envisaging of its implications, there was a contemporaneous realization of the inescapable need for regulation. Subsequently, in the first quarter of 2018, the State Bank of Pakistan (SBP), the country’s principal monetary authority, issued a circular, admonishing all cognate banking institutions, Development Financial Institutions (DFIs), Microfinance Banks (MFBs), and Payment System Operators (PSOs) to neither engage with nor facilitate customer transactions involving cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, Litecoin, Pakcoin, and others.

This memorandum served to elucidate the stance of the SBP, clarifying unequivocally that trading, promoting, or even the usage of such intangible virtual assets, were not legally recognized by the SBP. This directive effectively instituted a suspension on the trading and usage of cryptocurrencies in Pakistan, provoking the eventual cessation of operations by Urdubit, at the time, the country’s sole cryptocurrency exchange.

The rationale underpinning the SBP’s decision to discourage the usage of cryptocurrencies was indissolubly linked to numerous profoundly significant concerns. These concerns span an eclectic array of issues, from the incontrovertible lack of financial regulation to prospective utilization in illicit activities. Central to these concerns is the potentiality of cryptocurrencies to be leveraged as conduits for money laundering and financing of terrorism. The hyper-volatility characteristic of these currencies, and the attendant risks of precipitous fluctuation in value leading to substantial losses, was an additional factor underpinning this decision.

There was an additional significant issue at hand concerning the lack of tangible physical corroboration of cryptocurrencies. Because of this, the worth of these cryptocurrencies is irrevocably tied to speculative trading and market exigencies. This inherent feature renders cryptocurrencies as risky investment options. The term ‘extreme volatility’ encapsulates this risk in its entirety. It is entirely plausible for a digital currency to undergo drastic changes in value, culminating in momentous financial consequences.

Curiously, while the cryptographic dimension of currencies like Bitcoin guarantees transactional safety and identity theft prevention, it also carries potential risks. The clandestine misuse of such sophisticated technology with complete anonymity could conceivably lead to surreptitious transfers and illicit activities. Noting these potential risks, the Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) in Pakistan exercises vigilant surveillance over Bitcoin traders operating within the territorial jurisdiction of the country.

Despite the outlined concerns, the Pakistani government has not entirely dispensed with the potential benefits and utilities promised by cryptocurrencies and their underlying blockchain technology. In what may be perceived as a positive shift towards cryptocurrencies, the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) issued a document in November 2020, elucidating the potential advantages and implications for digital assets. These discussions indicate potential acceptance of cryptocurrencies in Pakistan, conditional on their operation within the ambit of a controlled, well-defined regulatory environment.

Pakistani regulatory bodies realize the need for striking a delicate balance between constraining illegal transactions and capitalizing on the potential that digital assets may offer. The formulation of future digital currency regulatory protocols in Pakistan has become a topic of focal interest for investors, cryptocurrency exchanges, and governmental agencies.

In conclusion, while cryptocurrencies harbour the potential to engender a revolution in financial transactions on a global and national scale, their adoption must be accompanied with the concurrent development of a robust regulatory framework. This framework must effectively address all financial, security, and legal risks associated with these digital assets. As Pakistan advances towards a digital future, the legal acceptance or repudiation of cryptocurrencies is poised to be a defining factor that will shape the contours of the future economic landscape in the country. Notably, this discourse is just commencing, and its potential ramifications on the Pakistani economy are a development worth monitoring closely.

About Author:

Nouman Ghumman is a renowned Pakistani lawyer with a focus in corporate and commercial laws. Holding an LLM degree from City, University of London, he utilizes his broad understanding of legal and financial landscapes to provide strategic counsel, particularly shaping Pakistan’s commercial legislation.

Version: 2.5.0